How Long to bake Meatballs at 375 degrees

by Ceejay

Meatballs are a nice, satisfying meal that’s rich in protein, and if you want it much healthier, you could make it with lean meat. Also, you could “customize” it by adding almost any kind of sauce and fillers, nobody gets left out.

However, for you to make really good meatballs, you need to know just how long you should bake it. So to answer the question: How long to bake meatballs at 375 degrees?

If you’re cooking at 375, ensure it stays in the oven for 25minutes, or until the internal temperature is about 165F. The meatballs should also appear uniformly brown.

How do I bake meatballs at 375 degrees?

How long to bake meatballs at 375

Place the meatballs on a cooking sheet, preferably lined with foil or parchment paper. Also ensure they aren’t touching each other and are spaced out (about an inch of space).

Bake uncovered for 25min until it’s evenly brown.

Incase you’re not familiar with the art of meatball-ery, allow me to explain the necessary ingredients

You see, meatballs are a very “customizable” meal and you can tweak it anyway you want.

Some people use a combination of different types of meat like beef, and pork. Others choose to use just one type of meat (beef). If you’re using only beef, I’d suggest you use 70 percent lean, and 90 percent lean beef if you’re mixing it with other types of meat.

You’ll also need:

  • 2 large eggs,
  • ¼ cup of grated parmesan cheese
  • ¼ cup of breadcrumbs
  • One and a half pounds of ground meat
  • 3 cloves of diced garlic
  • Salt,
  • Pepper,
  • ¼ cups of parsley (ensure its fresh)

Mix everything thoroughly in a bowl, and then roll them into balls of 1½ inches each.

How long to bake large meatballs at 375?

Some people prefer a large ball of meatball sitting on the top of their spaghetti (jumbo meatball), how do you prepare it?

Well, you’ll have to increase the size to 2inches in diameter. Also, since it’s bigger, it’ll require more time to be properly cooked. To achieve this, cook the meatballs at 375 degrees for 30 minutes as opposed to 25 minutes.

If you’re baking a lot of them, don’t forget to space them apart as well.

What if they’re frozen? How do you bake them?

Whether you made them earlier and stuffed them in the freezer or you bought them frozen, the preparation is the same. You only need to increase the time to about 35 minutes.

A better alternative is to defrost it in the microwave first before baking it, doing that reduces the chances of it getting really dry.

Can I cook meatballs in a pan of sauce?

You can cook meatballs in a pan of sauce with the help of a stove. However, you need to ensure that the pan has a good enough temperature to adequately cook the meatballs.

If you cook it this way, the meatball won’t get that nice and brown color. You’d have to bake it in the oven first and then put it in the sauce.

How do I make the meatball sauce in the first place?

You’ll need these ingredients:

  • Olive oil,
  • Sausage,
  • Pork loin cubed,
  • Onion,
  • Sugar,
  • Italian seasoning,
  • Minced garlic,
  • Tomato sauce,
  • Salt and pepper,
  • The cooked meatballs.


Crank up the heat, place a large deep pan over it, and then pour in olive oil.

Chop the onions, pour it in, and then let it stay in the oil for 3 minutes.

Pour in the minced garlic and cook for 3 minutes

Add the sausage and pork loin into the pan, keep stirring constantly until the meat becomes golden brown.

Pour the tomato sauce alongside sugar, pepper, salt, and Italian seasoning.

You can choose to add the cooked meatballs, all you need to do is pour it in and let it simmer for 4hrs.

Also, You can save it for later by freezing it.

Brief meatball/sauce tips

Make meatball sauce ahead of time.

The taste of meatball sauce becomes better with time. It’s best to make it a day before usage and then allow it to stay in the refrigerator overnight.

By the time you reheat it, it’ll taste better than it did when it was recently made

You can totally cook the meatballs inside the sauce. Just pour the meatballs into the sauce and let it simmer for 4 hours. This is to ensure the flavors soak into the meatball.

Taste the mixture before you form into balls

Once the mixture is ready, do ensure you taste it for spicing and seasoning before you begin to form it into balls. Relax, you’re not tasting raw meat, all you need to do is take a very small sample of the mixture and cook it with some oil in a frying pan.

Doing this will prevent the further stress associated with bringing out the meatballs, only to discover that the spicing isn’t right.

Can I cook meatballs in a slow cooker?

Yes you can cook it in a slow cooker. All you need to do is pour the meatball and the sauce into the slow cooker and then set the heat to low. Let it sit in there for about 7hrs.

If you’re in a hurry, you can crank up the heat and let it stay for about 4 hrs.

How to cook meatballs at 375 inside the microwave

Put the meatballs on a microwave tray and space them out, microwave for about 3mins. Turn the meatballs over and microwave for about 2mins. Check and ensure the internal temperature is about 165F.

Note: Your meatballs won’t get brown if you cook them in the microwave. If you need them brown, cook them in olive oil until the color changes to brown, and then transfer to the microwave to finish the cooking.

How do I check the internal temperature of the meatloaf?

You can easily do this by getting an instant-read, oven-safe thermometer. Stick the probe into the meatball until it’s in deep, and then read the temperature.

How to cook meatballs at 375 with the help of an air fryer

Preheat your air fryer until it attains the 375 degrees required

Arrange all the meatballs into a single layer

Reduce the heat by 25 degrees

Cook at the new degrees you reduced it to (350F) for about 15mins until it’s brown and the core temperature is 165F.

What can I serve meatballs with?

You can serve meatballs with mashed potatoes,

meatballs with rice,

meatballs with pasta.

What do I do with leftover meatballs? How do I store them?

Luckily, you can store meatballs in the refrigerator for future consumption. Do ensure they’re kept in an air tight container and that they don’t exceed 4 days in the fridge.

You can also store your meatballs in the freezer for a good 6 months. However, for the sake of the taste, it shouldn’t exceed 3 months in there.

FAQs on how long to bake meatballs at 375 degrees

What do I do if my meatballs taste rubbery?

If they taste rubbery, it’s because they don’t have adequate moisture. To fix this, you can re-moisten by adding a bit of tomato juice, milk, or even water.

You can even add ingredients that’ll retain the moisture. Ingredients like breadcrumbs, a bit of flour, or stuffing mix. You can add eggs too.

One of the main causes of your meatballs losing moisture is the fact that it’s been cooking for too long. It’s always ideal to remove them immediately they start uniformly turning brown.

Do meatballs get softer or harder the longer you cook them?

Meatballs get dryer and harder the longer you cook them. They even tend to become tougher by losing moisture.

You may also like

Leave a Comment